Skip to content
All guides for agents

Brokerage Compensation Models, Explained: Splits, Caps and Fees

How brokerages are paid from agents' commissions: splits, caps, flat fees, monthly fees, royalties and per-side fees, with the math and the questions to ask.

By Vlad Kruk, Principal Broker, Michigan real estate license 6502432786. Published . About 5 minutes to read.

The angled glass fins of a modern building facade against a blue sky

Every brokerage is paid out of the commissions its agents earn. What differs is how: a percentage, a fixed fee per deal, a monthly charge, or a mix, and whether the brokerage's share stops growing at some point in the year. Two plans with the same headline split can cost an agent very different amounts. Here is how each model works, with the math.

The words first

  • GCI (gross commission income) is the commission paid to the brokerage for your side of a deal, before anything is taken out. Every model is measured against it.
  • Company dollar is the part the brokerage keeps.
  • A side is one party's half of a transaction. Representing a buyer is one side; a listing you sell is another.

In Michigan, a salesperson may accept a commission only from the broker that employs them (MCL 339.2510). So every commission passes through the brokerage first, and the plan in your independent contractor agreement decides what comes back to you. For federal taxes, the IRS treats a licensed real estate agent as self-employed when substantially all of their pay is tied to sales rather than hours worked and a written contract says they will not be treated as an employee. What comes back to you is paid before income and self-employment taxes, which are yours to pay.

The split

An open blank notebook on a wooden desk with a mechanical pencil across its pages

A split names each party's share, agent first. At 80/20, you keep 80 percent and the brokerage keeps 20. On a $9,000 commission, that is $7,200 to you and $1,800 to the brokerage.

Without a cap, the split applies to every dollar, all year. The brokerage's share grows exactly as fast as your business does.

The cap

A cap is the most the split can take from you in a year. Once the brokerage's share reaches the cap, you keep 100 percent of the commission on your own business for the rest of the cap year.

To see where you would cap, divide the cap by the brokerage's share. An 80/20 split with a $5,000 cap is reached at $25,000 of GCI, because 20 percent of $25,000 is $5,000. A 70/30 split with a $15,000 cap would be reached at $50,000.

Three things to ask about any cap:

  1. When it resets. Some caps reset on January 1, others on the anniversary of the day you joined. An anniversary date changes the math in your first year, so run that year separately.
  2. What counts toward it. Ask whether royalties, per-side fees and fees on company leads count, or only the split.
  3. What you pay after it. Some plans charge a fee on every side after you cap. Ask for the dollar amount.

Graduated splits

A graduated split changes during the year as your GCI grows: the brokerage keeps a larger share of your first dollars and a smaller share later. For example, if a brokerage kept 30 percent of your first $30,000 and 20 percent after that, a $60,000 year would cost $9,000 plus $6,000, or $15,000. Ask when the tiers start over: if they reset each year, the higher share comes back every year.

Flat fee per transaction

Instead of a percentage, the brokerage charges a fixed amount on each side, such as $500. Your cost depends on how many deals you close, not on how large they are. Some flat-fee plans also have a cap, and some add monthly or annual fees.

100 percent plans with a monthly fee

You keep the whole commission and pay the brokerage a fixed amount each month, sometimes called a desk fee. You pay it in slow months too: at $500 a month, that is $6,000 a year whether you close two deals or twenty.

Franchise royalties

Some offices that belong to a national franchise charge agents a royalty, a percentage of each commission that goes to the franchisor, on top of the office's split. Ask whether the royalty has its own cap and whether it counts toward the office cap.

The fees around the plan

A ceiling of square coffers, each with a small skylight, seen from below

Fees are where plans with similar splits come apart. Look for:

  • Monthly or annual fees: technology, desk, administration.
  • Per-side fees: transaction, compliance review, risk management, or errors and omissions (E&O).
  • Who pays each per-side fee. Some plans charge it to the agent. Others disclose it to the client and collect it at closing, so it does not come out of your commission, but your client sees it.
  • Fees after the cap, per side.
  • Onboarding or sign-up fees.

Company leads and referral fees

A brokerage that passes you a lead may take a referral fee off the top: a percentage of the commission, before the split. Ask the percentage, whether it counts toward your cap, and whether it can ever apply to a client you brought yourself.

Costs that are the same anywhere

Some costs are yours at any brokerage: your Realtor association and MLS dues, your license renewal, and your own marketing. They belong in your budget but not in a comparison, unless a brokerage offers to cover them.

The same year under five plans

Illustrative example. Assumptions: $60,000 of GCI from your own business, from 10 sides of $6,000 each, in one calendar year; no company leads. The first four plans are hypothetical, built to show how each model behaves, not the terms of any real brokerage. Association and MLS dues are left out because they are the same everywhere.

PlanBrokerage keepsYou keep
70/30 split, no cap, no fees$18,000$42,000
80/20 split, no cap, $100 a month$13,200$46,800
100 percent plan, $500 a month$6,000$54,000
$500 per side, no cap$5,000$55,000
Raven: 80/20 to a $5,000 cap$5,000$55,000

Now a smaller year, with the same plans: $24,000 of GCI from 4 sides of $6,000.

PlanBrokerage keepsYou keep
70/30 split, no cap, no fees$7,200$16,800
80/20 split, no cap, $100 a month$6,000$18,000
100 percent plan, $500 a month$6,000$18,000
$500 per side, no cap$2,000$22,000
Raven: 80/20 to a $5,000 cap$4,800$19,200

In the smaller year, the flat-fee plan costs less than Raven's. A flat fee favors fewer, larger deals; a capped split favors agents who reach the cap. Raven's $395 transaction fee is paid by the client on each side and is not in these figures: in the 10-side year, clients would pay $3,950 in total. These are illustrative examples, not a guarantee; results vary with your own production and your own plan's terms.

Questions to ask any brokerage

  1. What is the split, and what is the cap in dollars?
  2. Does the cap reset on January 1 or on my anniversary?
  3. What counts toward the cap, and what does not?
  4. What do I pay on each side after I cap?
  5. What do I pay every month or year, even in a year I close nothing?
  6. What per-side fees are there, and who pays each one: me or my client?
  7. Is there a royalty or another fee with its own cap?
  8. What happens on company leads: the fee, and whether it counts toward the cap?
  9. Is there one plan, or a choice of plans?
  10. Can I see all of it in writing before I sign?

How the Raven plan works

  • An 80/20 split to a $5,000 cap, reached at $25,000 of your own GCI. The cap resets January 1. After it, you keep 100 percent on your own business for the rest of the year.
  • No monthly, desk, technology, E&O or onboarding fees.
  • A $395 transaction fee on each buyer and listing side, paid by your client and disclosed up front, before and after you cap. It is never charged on leases or on referral fees you earn by referring a client out.
  • On leads the office provides, a 25 percent referral fee before the split. It does not count toward the cap, and your own business never pays it.
  • One plan.
  • Your association and MLS dues are your own, as they are anywhere.

Your independent contractor agreement sets the final terms. The whole plan is written out on one page, with a calculator that puts your current plan next to it: run your own numbers.

General information, not legal or tax advice. Ask a Michigan attorney or tax professional about your situation.

Questions

What does an 80/20 split mean?

The agent keeps 80 percent of the commission on their side and the brokerage keeps 20 percent. On a $9,000 commission, that is $7,200 to the agent and $1,800 to the brokerage.

What is a cap in real estate?

The most the brokerage's split can take from an agent in a cap year. Once the brokerage's share reaches the cap, the agent keeps 100 percent of the commission on their own business until the cap resets. Fees outside the split may still apply.

How do I work out when I will reach a cap?

Divide the cap by the brokerage's share. An 80/20 split with a $5,000 cap is reached at $25,000 of gross commission income, because 20 percent of $25,000 is $5,000.

Is a lower split always the better plan?

No. Monthly fees, per-side fees, royalties and fees after the cap can cost more than a few points of split. Add up a full year at your own production before you compare.

Does a transaction fee paid by the client cost the agent anything?

It does not come out of the agent's commission, but the client pays it, so it has to be disclosed to the client before they sign and shown on the closing statement.

More guides for agents